Page 1 of 4
My First Piece..
Posted: Mar 25, 2008 2:55pm
by Meushi
The following link is my first piece i have drawn and coloured in myself.
It is my own character called Kisa and is based on Naruto.
http://i5.photobucket.com/albums/y154/l ... /Kisa1.jpg
Please be gentle with me... I am new at this
Re: My First Piece..
Posted: Mar 29, 2008 10:54am
by Meushi
Aww no critisms.. there are more to come
Re: My First Piece..
Posted: Mar 29, 2008 11:55am
by Slash
The talent section doesn't get a whole lotta lovin' unfortunately. Seems like the only ones that get a lot of attentions are those that are aimed at it.
I like your drawing very much. You didn't scrap on details, like some people do. It seems like I can derive two things from this piece: Shes from the Uchiha clan, and she's a traitor to the leaf village O_o
Keep up the good work, hope to see more from ya.
Re: My First Piece..
Posted: Mar 29, 2008 12:59pm
by Commander Sparx
Ok, I know i should be gentle, but if you want to become good you will have to take some constructive criticism.
The head is too big, but it is almost in the right shape, it’s also a little too wide. The eyes are too far apart they need to be just coming off the top of the nose. You can feel your nose then follow it up towards your fore head and you eyes are just there. The mouth is ok, but for a moth like that you should but a little crease under the lower lip. The hair looks too on the top of the head. The arms need to come down more, because if you look at your arms they go past your waist. The shoulders and bust are ok and the stomach is good too. Because your character is a girl she needs hips. And the legs are too straight. The ankles need to slim down as they come to the feet. Depending on the age the upper legs are different. For someone who is young they will be quite thin and someone 18 and above with have thick upper legs. Oh and use shading and highlights. The hands need work but i no noting on hands, lol.
But i like the feet, i cannot do feet. V_V
But, it is a very good star, you should practice more.
Re: My First Piece..
Posted: Apr 01, 2008 12:26pm
by Meushi
Okay I can take it but I halfly already knew that as my friend told me and I am currently drawing a new version of Kisa and is ready to be scanned when I get the chance.
My friend is sooo... much better than me and has helped me by lending her 'How to Draw Manga book'
BTW.... thanks ^^
Re: My First Piece..
Posted: Apr 08, 2008 9:29pm
by Demyx
A) I'm going to say everything that's wrong, and I'm going to be blunt about it, even if already covered by Sparxy. I will come off as rude.
The proportions are so far off, I can't begin to cover them. First thing: Compared to the body, the head is WAY too big. The average human body when measured by the size of the head is about five heads high (According to my art teacher.) Legs are not sticks. Unless, of course, your character is Janet Jackson and has no knees. Which, by the looks of it, she doesn't. The feet are too small and blocky. There's virtually no distinction between hips and stomach, and I see a REALLY bad distinction of a ribcage, but no boobs. Unless those lumps are supposed to be boobs. The arms are too short. Your hands touch about mid thigh. Again, no elbows. The hands are... undefinable. You need to work on the definition, proportion, and shape. As for the head... *clears throat* The eyes are horrible, too far apart, and the head is too wide to boot. The nose is too small, and too high on the head. The chin is really round, and unless the character is heavier set, you might want to point it a little bit. Again, Definition. The face takes up all teh room. Your character has no forehead, and no top of the head. The hair is blocky, uneven, and badly defined. Whatever shading you tried to do failed. Miserably. The coloring needs work too. And I hate the blank stare on your characters face. It doesn't even have meaning.
B) Those How to Draw Manga books aren't very good. Believe me. The best you can do is read manga and practice by copying what others draw or using their techniques to do your own characters and develope your own style. The How to books are usually by americans who know jack crap about what they're doing. Sure, they might look good, but they're still americans trying to pass it off as real manga.
C) If you can't get what I'm saying, ignore it, or get mad at it, you've got no one to blame but yourself. Even if you're new, you have to understand that not everyone will like what you do, and older, more expirienced artists will most likely look at you and start shooting off what's wrong. Honestly. If you can't take the bad criticism with the good, then you're pretty screwed.
Re: My First Piece..
Posted: Apr 09, 2008 3:42am
by Commander Sparx
You’re Welcome.
Re: My First Piece..
Posted: Apr 09, 2008 7:26pm
by Gaming Goddess
Don't post first pieces.
No one cares, we all just think it's bad.
Come back when you have talent.
Re: My First Piece..
Posted: Apr 10, 2008 7:56pm
by Demyx
Gaming Goddess wrote:
Come back when you have talent.
If she ever GETS talent.
Re: My First Piece..
Posted: Apr 11, 2008 12:42pm
by Cheshire Cat
your arms are differnt sizes *snicker* sorry
Re: My First Piece..
Posted: Apr 11, 2008 6:20pm
by Demyx
Cheshire Cat wrote:your arms are differnt sizes *snicker* sorry
You don't have to apologize if its true, Axel!
Re: My First Piece..
Posted: Apr 12, 2008 8:25pm
by Aiden
OH.
MY.
GOD!!!!!!!!!!
ARE THOSE FINGERS OR DOES HE-SHE HAVE [censored] FREDDY KRUGER FINGERS?!?!?!?!?!?!?
GOD DAMN, THAT'S AN UGLY BETCH!
Re: My First Piece..
Posted: Apr 12, 2008 8:54pm
by scorpionwarrior
Here's what I think.
It's good. Hands and proportions might not be perfect but if you want to learn how to do better with the proportion and stuff, do what I do and use Figurines (star war toys are good for this) and look at books and anything you can. After a while you get used to it
Re: My First Piece..
Posted: Apr 13, 2008 12:43pm
by Slash
And the award for most ignorant post of the year goes to...
Oh, we have a 4-way tie. Contructive critism anyone, or just blatant stabs at trying to be funny to boost ego?
It needs work, but for a first piece, you're well on your way. Anyone else have a Bachelor's degree in Graphic Design? Didn't think so.
Re: My First Piece..
Posted: Apr 13, 2008 1:08pm
by scorpionwarrior
I'm going for my Diploma in Graphics

on my second year now. I only see 3 people however making "ignorant" posts.
Btw it's better than my first drawings I was doing. NO-ONE is good when they first start so very well done.
Re: My First Piece..
Posted: Apr 13, 2008 1:22pm
by Slash
Graphics is a great field. Pays very well and there's always a need for it. I worked at a print center for a year, which was mediocre pay, but then whenever I moved into vinyl design, I started out at $24 bucks an hour, which isn't too shabby for starting pay. Web is where most of the money is, unfortunately I hate coding.
The ignorant posts I was refering to belonged to Aiden, Demyx, Chesire and GG.